Thursday, December 6, 2012

NY subway incident

I just finished reading a piece in USA Today about R. Umar Abbasi. He's the guy who took the images of that poor soul about to be hit by the subway train. He's been criticized widely for not rescuing Ki-Suck Han from the train. First of all, Mr Abbasi is a trained freelance photojournalist. I'm not certain, but I'm fairly confident there are no classes in journalism school describing how to rescue the subjects of photos from their demise and, as he was untrained in how to do this, attempting this likely would have resulted in two deaths instead of one. My second point is there are many examples of photojournalists who have taken the shot with their cameras rather than attempting to take the shot at rescue. One of the most dramatic I recall was captured during the Vietnam War. The journalist captured the precise moment a Vietnamese boy was summarily executed by a South Vietnamese Army soldier with a Colt M1911. Should he have intervened? To what end? His intervention would have only resulted in his death, too! Mr. Abbasi did his job under the most terrifying circumstance. I hope I never have to take a shot like that, but if I were in his position at that moment, I would have done the same thing.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Blaming the gun, in this case, is wrong

Everyone in the world is all distraught over Bob Costas and Jason Whitlock, and I can see some of their points. Jovan Belcher owned guns, and he used at least one of them to take the life of the mother of his child and his own life, but guns aren't the issue here, and neither is domestic violence, although they both played a role. It's my opinion that what caused this unspeakably tragic event will probably be linked to head injury. If I'm correct, and Mr. Belcher did suffer from Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy, then we also share some of the burden of responsibility for this, especially if we now do nothing to prevent young men from destroying their brains playing collegiate football. You see, the NFLPA addressed the issue of CTE by standing firm in their collective bargaining negotiations to limit full contact practices to one day per week. By doing this, they ensure that players rarely receive more than 500 or so hits to their head per season. 700 hits per season is considered a rate at which the brain will heal. More than 700, the brain tends to not heal resulting in damage to the areas of the brain that allow us to think and reason,  the same area that may have prevented Jovan Belcher from his horrible crimes. The NCAA has decided not to limit the amount of contact that college athletes are subjected to. So, as more of these former student athletes commit heinous crimes in the future, can we all remember the NCAA's role?


It’s Time

Given the recent tragedy that was endured last weekend (December 1, 2012) in Kansas City, and based on other research that I have seen presented, I have arrived on the conclusion that I will no longer support NCAA college football by watching it, ever. What I’ve learned is that we are destroying the brains of young men who are supposed to be students first and athletes second. I recently watched the show Real Sports on HBO. The segment I watched was aired the week before Jovan Belcher committed his atrocious acts. Many universities are conducting studies to better understand the phenomenon of head injuries on college football players. They have all come to the same conclusion. The more hits one takes to the head, the greater the odds of them never recovering from said injuries. They suggest that if hits on the head are limited to less than 700 per season, the odds of never recovering from those injuries, or of any long-term effects from those injuries are insignificant. Most players suffer over 1000 hits to the head in a single season. The single most effective means to reduce the majority of hits to the head is to limit contact during practice. By doing so, over half of those 1000 hits would be eliminated. The NFL Players Association realized this and through their collective bargaining process, successfully had the days of full contact practice reduced to once per week. Who advocates for the welfare of the student athlete? It’s supposed to be the NCAA, but apparently, they’ve seen dollar signs and opted to implement only minimal protections for the student athletes that play football, so I’ve opted to turn off the games, even the upcoming bowl games. My contention is that if enough of us do this, we can damage the NCAA where it appears to matter most, in its bank account.  I watched a young man named Derek Owens, who received straight A’s for grades in high school, except one B he received in a college level course. Derek was a gifted student athlete and was sought for scholarships by Harvard and Yale and other Ivy League schools. He chose to stay at home and play for Central Arkansas. By the close of his third season at Central Arkansas, Derek would be flunking classes. When he failed a physics class, he left school knowing something was wrong with him. The problem with all this is that these young men will receive nothing to assist them later in life when the end result of their injuries leaves them completely incapacitated. Derek is just shit out of luck when (and I pray this isn’t the case) he begins to show sign of dementia in his thirties. It’s bad enough that an NFL player who winds up speaking through a computer that tracks his head movement allowing him to type sentences has to endure his injuries, but he has the support of the leagues insurance program to assist him in his plight, and he has the NFLPA to thank for those things, but the NCAA has CHOSEN not to advocate for those young men and they have no program in place to care for those athletes later in their lives. Once the student athlete is done with school and with football, he is on his own. Hopefully they will have enough brain left to receive a good degree that will land them in a stellar job so that their shortened career will be the most profitable it can be. Then they can take care of themselves.

Then there’s Jovan Belcher. Hopefully, for the sake of his memory and for the sake of those family and friends that survive him, he was suffering from something beyond his control, only an autopsy will show for sure, and I’m not sure if it will be conclusive given the nature of his fatal injury. It doesn’t seem like too much of a stretch for us to draw a reasonable conclusion from the studies. The area of the brain that seems to be the most susceptible to these hits are the areas that allow us to reason, and our ability to reason allows us to make informed, rational decisions (like shooting someone your angry with is wrong). It seems to me the odds are high that this is partly, if not mostly to blame for Jovan Belcher’s demise, and if this is the case, then we, the viewer and fan of the sport have some responsibility in this tragedy, too. Maybe we can absolve ourselves due to the ignorance surrounding the subject, after all. It hasn’t been known what the dangers of these head injuries were until recently, but now we know and now we must question our support of any program that will not take the real and necessary steps to insure this widespread phenomenon is nipped in the bud. Surely we can see that by endorsing this sport, we’re contributing to loosing a Mr. Hyde for each of these young Doctor Jekylls we create with these injuries and WE or our loved ones could be the unintended victims of the powder kegs that head injuries create. Kasandra Perkins and young Zoe did nothing to deserve this and IF it could have been prevented by simply practicing in full pads once a week instead of three or four times per week, then I, for one, would be thrilled to watch a game that may not be played to the same quality as before, but in turn will leave many fewer bruised and battered and helpless for life, if not dead. It is for these reasons that I have made my decision. I love the sport of football. I enjoy watching college football more so than professional football. I love the rivalries the game day climate, the student fans and their raucous, rowdy displays in the stands and outside the stadiums, but I cannot condone the NCAA’s refusal to protect what should be students first and athletes second. I feel they’va abandoned their responsibility and they should be punished for this.

TW