I did some research last night regarding the effectiveness
of surprise in warfare. The only real research I could find was conducted by a man named Professor BartonS. Whaley and it was located on the Central Intelligence Agency’s website.
According to Dr. Whaley, surprise causes a favorable outcome for the initiator
98% of the time. Dr. Whaley further asserts that 34% of the time, the element
of surprise results in an outcome that exceeds the expectations of the
initiating force. Only 2% of the time has the initiating force lost the battle.
The kill ratio of initiators to defenders is one to 15 when the initiator has
the tactical advantage of surprise. When the defender knows he’s going to be
attacked, the ratio falls to 1 to 1.7. Bear in mind that these data are from
military conflicts between 1914 and 1968. These were armies squaring off on one
another. Both sides had training in tactics and command and control structure
in place at the time of the attacks. The defenders assets still failed them 49
out of 50 times and in 17 of those 49 their assets failed them tremendously.
Given this data, what can we draw from this in light of the
mass shootings that the nation has experienced? I think it’s fair to say that
the teachers at Newtown were not trained soldiers with command and control
structures for tactical situations in place. Nor were the moviegoers in Aurora,
Colorado or the college students at Virginia Tech. Wouldn’t that make the
element of surprise an even more effective tactic? I know some of you think
that an armed faculty, moviegoers or college students would have an element of
surprise, but wouldn’t the shooter be expecting some resistance either from the
police or from someone in the crowd he was shooting at? I don’t think I’m out
of line when I say that, in my opinion, any armed civilian trying to defend
against this would have been just as surprised as the unarmed victims were.
Remember that 1 to 15 kill ratio, which means that one can logically assume
there would have to be 15 armed faculty members, moviegoers or college students
to stop their respective lone gunmen, and all 15 would have likely died. Those
aren’t very good odds are they? Based on this common sense, I think it’s plain
to see that the National Rifle Association is lying to us when it comes to
arming the crowd to defend against these types of attacks.
Certain other advocates of gun rights have been reminding us
lately about how baseball bats, knives, hammers, etc are used to commit murder,
as well. They want to know why no one is clamoring for their regulation as
lethal weapons. Are they serious? How many people can one kill in ten minutes
with these types of weapons? The gunman at Virginia Tech killed 32 people in
about that time frame. Could anyone do that with a knife? We’re talking about
degrees of lethality here and if they can’t wrap their heads around that, then
why do they have guns? Why not knives, or baseball bats or hammers, or maybe a
mace or battle-ax? This brings us back to tactics, too. If anyone were to break
into my home (yes I’m a gun owner) I hope to hell they’re armed with a
penknife, but any of the aforementioned will work for me, too. This gives me
somewhat better odds than if they were armed as well as or better than I and
had the element of surprise. So why would the NRA not want to keep guns out of
criminals hands? They’re claim is
that there’s just no effective way to keep guns 100% out of criminals hands,
but is that really true? Municipalities and insurance companies require
homeowners with swimming pools to build fences, tall fences, around their pools
to prevent small children from drowning in them. Are they 100% effective?
Should we do away with the fence requirement? Owners of large aggressive dogs
are required by some municipalities to have large fences for many of the same
reasons. Should we drop this requirement, too? How about seatbelt laws or drunken
driving laws, have they been 100% effective in preventing those tragedies?
Should we abandon our efforts there, as well? I think my point is made here.
The NRA does use one piece of propaganda that I do agree
with. “Guns don’t kill people, people kill people.” I couldn’t agree more, so
why don’t we make a concerted effort to keep guns from falling into the wrong
hands? As I stated earlier, I want the person who attempts a break in at my
house to be armed with as little as humanly possible. I figure, with my alarm
system’s warning, I can implement an action plan to overwhelm the perpetrator’s
element of surprise with incredible force. If Wayne La Pierre and the rest of
the NRA leadership felt the same way, they would stand up for stricter
background check for all gun transactions.
About me:
I received my first shooting lesson from my dad when I was 5
years old. I’m 48 now, so I’ve been shooting for 43 years. I have that first
rifle my dad bought for my use, still. I also have a .222 Remington chambered
Model 70 Winchester that he got for me when I was ten years old. I have a Colt Frontier
Scout single action revolver in 22 long rifle. It belonged to my grandfather
and was left to me when he died. My father taught me to reload when I was
around 10. I hand loaded ammunition fro his rifles as well as the ones I shot.
As an adult, I have purchased three guns, one Colt 22 pistol that was stolen
and reported stolen, one Mossberg 12 gauge shotgun and one Colt Gold Cup
National Match M1911. I had proper background check done for each purchase.
Todd Wade
No comments:
Post a Comment